Guides

The $660,000 Shiny Rayquaza PSA 10 Was a Fake Slab

A B.C. collector says he paid US$660,000 for a PSA 10 Shiny Rayquaza. PSA told CTV News the holder is fraudulent, though the card is believed to be real.

The official Call of Legends Shiny Rayquaza card (SL10), illustrated by Noriko Hotta, on a dark background.
On this page

Jesse Peng, a collector from Richmond, B.C., says he paid US$660,000 (about C$935,000) for a 2011 Call of Legends Shiny Rayquaza sold to him as a PSA 10. On 11 November 2026, PSA told CTV News it had identified a fraudulent PSA holder associated with the card. CTV reports that the card itself is believed to be real, but it is not an authentic PSA 10, which significantly reduces its value.

What Peng says he bought

Peng says he bought a 2011 Call of Legends Shiny Rayquaza sold as a PSA 10, PSA’s highest grade. He told CTV News: “It’s one of the rarest cards in the world.”

Peng runs a Pokémon card shop with his wife, and a tech startup building software to identify counterfeit collectibles, according to CTV’s report as carried by Yo Vancouver. Dexerto also describes him as the owner of PDGR.

He told CTV he paid US$660,000, about C$935,000, through a Pokémon card broker, in cryptocurrency. CTV’s headline put the loss at “nearly $1 million”, which is the Canadian-dollar figure.

Peng trusted the go-between. He told CTV: “This is someone that I’ve seen do big deals in the past and has a pretty good reputation.” He added: “So I trusted the middleman’s ability to authenticate the card.”

The first look, then the doubts

The card arrived by courier. Peng told CTV: “When I received the card, I initially looked at it and I was like, this is the card of my dreams.”

Peng first told the story on PDGR’s YouTube channel, and Dexerto reported his account on 3 November 2026. Dexerto quotes him saying: “It looked like a very clean card and the label looked very very real.” He also told Dexerto: “This is so clean that it’s a little bit suspicious to me.”

The problem, Peng said, was the fugitive ink on the label. He told Dexerto it did not match the authentic version on other cards in his collection. At that stage he put it this way: “The card is real, the label is real, the only thing that they couldn’t do is get the fugitive ink right.” That was Peng’s own reading, before PSA made its statement.

Peng told CTV that a closer look raised questions about the PSA 10 label, so he ran it through the software his startup is developing. “When I put it through our system, our system flagged it to being fake,” he told CTV. “I was so in denial that I was mad. I was like, if this is fake, then what is real?”

What PSA told CTV News

PSA says the holder is fraudulent. Peng sent the card to PSA for review, and PSA told CTV News Vancouver on 11 November 2026 that its authentication process identified a fraudulent PSA holder associated with the card.

CTV reports that the card itself is believed to be real, and that PSA determined it was not an authentic PSA 10, which significantly reduces its value. No source gives a new value for the card as it stands.

PSA also told CTV that fraudsters have “become more sophisticated in producing deceptive cards and altered items” as high-end collectibles rise in value.

A PSA spokesperson said the company would not comment on active investigations. Emails obtained by CTV show PSA is working with law enforcement in Peng’s case. No agency has been named and no arrest has been reported.

The broker declined CTV’s request for comment. Peng told CTV he does not think the broker knowingly took part, but believes the broker should be held accountable. He is exploring legal options. “Hopefully I can partially recover some of my lost funds,” he told CTV. “But if not, then it will be a very expensive learning lesson.”

DateWhat happenedReported by
3 November 2026Peng’s account of buying the “PSA 10” Shiny Rayquaza, first told on PDGR’s YouTube channelDexerto
8 November 2026Roman Pioneer of CheckCOA posts about the Japanese copy-label postsX (@renoipgp)
9 November 2026Max Long posts a video of an AliExpress PSA-style label listingX (@MaxLonged)
10 November 2026Report on AliExpress copy labels and cases, citing Long, Pioneer and PokemonlanaDexerto
11 November 2026PSA tells CTV News it found a fraudulent PSA holder on Peng’s cardCTV News Vancouver

Sources: CTV News Vancouver, Dexerto, X posts by Max Long and Roman Pioneer (checked 17 November 2026).

Why a certification number is not enough on its own

A real cert number on a label does not prove the slab is real. Counterfeiters can copy genuine numbers from public records, so a lookup can show a correct card name and grade for a fake holder.

PSA makes this point itself. As reported by Dexerto, PSA warns that checking a certification number does not remove the risk of a counterfeit, that counterfeiters can copy real numbers from public records, and that buyers should compare cards with PSA’s own images, check the case for tampering, and buy from trusted sellers.

Our guide to fake PSA slabs and super clones explains why a genuine certification record cannot, by itself, establish that the holder in front of you is genuine. If you are newer to graded cards, our explainer on what a slab is covers the basics.

Copy labels listed for about $4 on AliExpress

On 10 November 2026, Dexerto reported AliExpress listings for PSA-style copy labels costing about $4. This is a separate story: no source reports any link between these listings and Peng’s Rayquaza holder.

Max Long 🚀@MaxLonged
0:28

You can go on AliExpress and make your own PSA labels? 😬

Watch on X
Max Long’s 9 November video of the AliExpress listing, the one Dexerto cited.

According to Dexerto’s 10 November report, collectibles commentator Max Long shared a video of a listing offering custom PSA-style labels for almost any card. The labels came with front and back designs, barcodes, QR codes and a holographic patch. The listing appeared to be priced at $4.05, with more than 5,000 sales displayed. It is advertised as a customisable label, not as a PSA-graded collectible, but collectors fear the designs could be put on raw cards and resold as genuine slabs.

Japanese collector Pokemonlana posted screenshots of the same style of label using two different PSA certification numbers: one on a Dark Persian front label and a different number on the back. They asked how buyers could tell copies from real labels.

What CheckCOA found

Roman Pioneer, founder of the authentication database CheckCOA, looked at the listing and similar products. He found AliExpress stores offering custom front and back labels alongside unsealed card cases.

Roman Pioneer@renoipgp

I went through the fake @PSAcard label posts from Japan today. On AliExpress you can order PSA front and back labels for any card, with a silver patch that catches the light like the real one. Some carry real, active cert numbers. Also: genuine PSA 10 and BGS 10 labels sold … Show more

Watch on X
Roman Pioneer of CheckCOA, 8 November, after going through the Japanese posts.

Dexerto reported these details:

  • One store, called “BEST REPLICA LABELS YOU’LL FIND”, advertised a “DIY custom rating card label” and had reportedly sold 170 units with a 4.7-star rating.
  • Buyer photos from that store showed labels using PSA certification numbers tied to a Paldean Fates Mew ex and a Rocket Dark Gyarados. Both numbers matched real PSA records, so a buyer who only checked the number could see a genuine card description and grade.
  • A second store, High Quality Cards Store, advertised custom labels made from details the buyer supplied. Its product video showed a copied PSA label tilted under a light so the silver patch reflected much like the security feature on a genuine label.
  • One label used a deactivated PSA number. Another used an active certification number for a GEM MT 10 One Piece Zoro card.
  • A separate Japanese listing showed genuine PSA, BGS and ARS labels removed from their original cases and sold together for ¥6,800. The labels were authentic, but collectors warned they could be put into new cases with different cards. CheckCOA marked those loose labels as suspected rather than confirmed counterfeits.

Not everyone thinks the copies are undetectable. Some collectors have pushed back, saying copies can still be spotted through fugitive ink, print quality and missing security patterns. Peng specifically identified a mismatch in the label’s fugitive ink.

PSA’s 2025 Fraud Report lists Pokémon as its top counterfeited category and reports a 125% year-over-year increase in counterfeit Pokémon cards. Dexerto cited the same report in its 10 November coverage.

How collectors are being told to check a slab

The advice from PSA and from Peng comes down to the same thing: check the whole slab, not just the number, and get a second opinion when you are unsure. PSA told CTV News that buyers should take extreme care when buying high-value raw cards on peer-to-peer sites.

For graded cards, PSA’s statement, as quoted by Cardboard Police in its summary of the CTV report, says: “When buying encapsulated cards, collectors should always verify the certification number and scans in PSA’s public database, inspect the physical holder for tamper-evident features, and submit items for official review whenever uncertainty exists.”

Taken together with PSA’s advice reported by Dexerto and Peng’s own comments to CTV, that gives a simple checklist:

  1. Look up the cert number, then go further. Compare the card in the slab with PSA’s own scans and images, not just the name and grade on the record.
  2. Check the holder. Look for signs of tampering and check the tamper-evident features on the case.
  3. Look closely at the label. Collectors point to fugitive ink, print quality and security patterns as the places copies tend to fall down.
  4. Send it to PSA if in doubt. PSA says to submit items for official review whenever there is uncertainty, which is what Peng did.
  5. Verify independently before you pay. Peng’s advice through CTV is to verify a high-value card independently before buying.
  6. Avoid paying in cryptocurrency where you can. Peng told CTV this was part of his lesson.
  7. Buy from trusted sellers. PSA’s advice, as reported by Dexerto.

Peng called counterfeits a “very, very big problem” in the collecting community. For safer places to buy, see our guide to where to buy Pokémon cards in the UK.

Getting the cards you actually want

If you want to see the actual slab, label and all, before you pay, Tilt is the place to go. UK sellers show the actual card on video, in live shows or in a Clip, so you can look over the label and case before buying.

You get graded slabs, sealed product, box breaks and rip and ship from UK sellers, with no queues, and there are no fees on items bought directly from a Clip.

Every order comes with Buyer Protection: if a card is not as described, arrives damaged, turns out to be fake or never shows up, you are covered. Watching the card on video works alongside the checks above, so compare what you see with PSA’s scans before you bid.

Download Tilt to watch UK sellers show the actual card on video.

Frequently asked questions

Was the PSA 10 Shiny Rayquaza fake?

PSA told CTV News on 11 November 2026 that it found a fraudulent PSA holder associated with the card. CTV reports the 2011 Call of Legends Shiny Rayquaza itself is believed to be real, but it is not an authentic PSA 10.

How much did Jesse Peng pay for the Shiny Rayquaza?

Peng told CTV News he paid US$660,000, about C$935,000, through a Pokémon card broker, in cryptocurrency. Dexerto, which first reported his account on 3 November 2026, said “over $660,000”.

What did PSA say about the Shiny Rayquaza?

PSA told CTV News its authentication process found a fraudulent PSA holder and that fraudsters have become more sophisticated as high-end collectibles rise in value. A PSA spokesperson would not comment on active investigations, and emails obtained by CTV show PSA is working with law enforcement in the case.

Were AliExpress copy labels used on this Rayquaza?

No source reports any link between the AliExpress copy labels and Peng’s Rayquaza holder. Dexerto reported the AliExpress listings as a separate story on 10 November 2026, the day before PSA’s statement to CTV News.

Is checking a PSA certification number enough?

No. PSA, as reported by Dexerto, warns that counterfeiters can copy real numbers from public records, and some copy labels found on AliExpress carried real, active PSA certification numbers.

How can I check a PSA slab before buying?

Compare the card with PSA’s own scans in its public database, check the holder for tampering and tamper-evident features, and look closely at the label’s fugitive ink and print quality. If you are unsure, PSA advises submitting the item for official review.

← Back to all posts
1.195.0